Records include games against Division I opponents only.
Conference Leader is the team in the conference with the highest Elo ranking.
KEY:
NC Rec: Non-Conference Record
NC WP: Non-Conference Win Percent
| Conference | Elo | Rank | NC Rec | NC WP | Team | Elo | Rank | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Missouri Valley | 1397 | 1 | 21 - 14 | 0.6000 | North Dakota State | 1697 | 1 | ||
| Colonial Athletic | 1381 | 2 | 25 - 20 | 0.5556 | James Madison | 1512 | 7 | ||
| Ivy League | 1377 | 3 | 18 - 6 | 0.7500 | Princeton | 1571 | 2 | ||
| Independent FCS | 1352 | 4 | 11 - 10 | 0.5238 | North Dakota | 1365 | 45 | ||
| Big Sky | 1350 | 5 | 22 - 30 | 0.4231 | Eastern Washington | 1554 | 3 | ||
| Southern | 1346 | 6 | 9 - 16 | 0.3600 | Wofford | 1455 | 14 | ||
| Big South | 1329 | 7 | 13 - 17 | 0.4333 | Kennesaw State | 1543 | 4 | ||
| Ohio Valley | 1322 | 8 | 10 - 21 | 0.3226 | Jacksonville State | 1463 | 13 | ||
| Southland | 1308 | 9 | 6 - 16 | 0.2727 | Nicholls State | 1440 | 18 | ||
| MEAC | 1297 | 10 | 7 - 21 | 0.2500 | North Carolina A&T | 1500 | 10 | ||
| Northeast | 1293 | 11 | 10 - 20 | 0.3333 | Duquesne | 1443 | 17 | ||
| Pioneer League | 1281 | 12 | 2 - 16 | 0.1111 | San Diego | 1445 | 16 | ||
| Patriot League | 1275 | 13 | 8 - 28 | 0.2222 | Colgate | 1496 | 11 | ||
| SWAC | 1262 | 14 | 1 - 26 | 0.0370 | Southern | 1422 | 21 | ||